WELCOME !


WELCOME! CrossCurrents aims to provoke thought and enrich faith by interpreting current events in the light of Catholic tradition. I hope you find these columns both entertaining and clarifying. Your feedback and comments are welcome! See more about me and my work at http://home.comcast.net/~bfmswain/onlinestorage/index.html or contact me directly at bfswain@juno.com NOTE: TO READ OR WRITE COMMENTS, CLICK ON THE TITLE OF A POST.

Showing posts with label same sex marriage. Show all posts
Showing posts with label same sex marriage. Show all posts

Friday, September 4, 2015

#436: Public Officials Cannot use Faith to Justify Violating their Oath of Office.

   The  public memory of most people is pretty short. Too often, if it happened before you were born, it's in the history books but not in your mind. Yesterday this public amnesia led to a crisis that never should have happened.
 
    Rowan County (Kentucky) Clerk Kim Davis was jailed after U.S. District Court Judge David Bunning found her in contempt of court for refusing to issue marriage licenses to same-sex couples, and for saying through her lawyers that she would not authorize any of her employees to issue licenses in her absence. 

    "My conscience will not allow it," Davis told Bunning. "God's moral law convicts me and conflicts with my duties."

    Of course, Davis is entitled to her beliefs--and many Catholics join her in believing that same-sex marriage is wrong (although, as I've often written, they may fail to distinguish the Sacrament of Matrimony from mere civil marriage). Same-sex marriage, though legal, remains controversial. But the conflict between faith and official duties should NOT be a matter of controversy these days, even if the likes of Ted Cruz claims that  “This is wrong. This is not America." He is a Presidential candidate, yet he too forgets the lesson of the 1960 Presidential election.

   Fifty-five years ago next week (September 12, 1960) John  F. Kennedy spoke before the Greater Houston Ministerial Association, a group of Protestant ministers concerned that a Catholic President would impose his religious beliefs on the rest of the country. JFK took the opportunity to spell out his views on how public officials manage to balance faith and their duties. His explanation stands as the moral standard for all officials today:

    “I do not speak for my church on public matters,” Kennedy said, “and the church does not speak for me.” He said that he would always make his decisions “in accordance with what my conscience tells me." 

    Finally, Kennedy acknowledged the possibility of a circumstance where his Catholic conscience might conflict with his oath of office. “And if that time should ever come,” he said, “when my office would require me to either violate my conscience or violate the national interest, then I would resign the office.”

    Kim Davis, like JFK, was an elected official who had  to take an oath before assuming her office. She now says her faith "conflicts with my duties." I respect both her faith and her acknowledgment of such a conflict, which JFK also recognized.

   But JFK had it right: in case of such a conflict, if a public official cannot perform according to their oath, they must resign. We can accept that Ms. Davis cannot, in conscience, do what God forbids. But she also vowed to follow the law, and if she cannot, she also cannot claim that breaking her oath is God's will. She cannot violate her conscience--but neither can she violate her oath of office. Her moral duty, therefore, is to resign. 

    In America, public officials have a right to their personal faith, but they cannot hold the law hostage to that faith. They must follow the law, or relinquish their office.

© Bernard F. Swain PhD 2015


Saturday, June 6, 2015

#431: We Need the Right Kind of Leadership

Events in Ireland El Salvador can teach powerful lessons for the leaders of the Church in the United States. 

The recent Pew Research Center study on religious affiliation brings disquieting news: the number of American Catholics who have stopped practicing their faith has increased, especially among the millennial generation, since the last Pew study in 2007.  The Catholic Church is losing members faster than ever, and faster than any other Christian church.
But this begs the question: how can we stop, or even reverse, this trend?  I suspect there is no single answer, but last week’s events in two other countries suggest that one answer is: we need the right kind of leadership.
These countries are Ireland and El Salvador, and their contrasting experience shows the difference between two kinds of leadership: the right kind and the wrong kind.
This contrast may surprise us, since on the surface these two countries, though distant, are similar in several respects.  Both are small countries with small populations  (Ireland 4.6 million, El Salvador 6.3 million).  Both have overwhelmingly Catholic populations.  Both countries’ church hierarchies have had powerful cultural and political influence.  Both share a history of oppression at the hands of a foreign colonizer.  And both have seen grinding poverty.
Yet last week we saw sharply contrasting events.  In Ireland, the vast majority of Catholics, refusing to follow the Irish hierarchy’s opposition to same sex marriage, approved a constitutional revision legalizing civil marriage between gays.  That same week, thousands of Salvadorans attended (and millions celebrated) the beatification of Archbishop Oscar Romero, soon to be Saint Oscar Romero.

Common sense tells us that leaders cannot lead if no one follows.  This raises a new question: why did Romero inspire such following, while the Irish hierarchy inspired rejection?  As we Americans witness so many (especially young) Catholics rejecting their Church, the question is both practical and urgent.  So the cases of Ireland and El Salvador are not just relevant, but also instructive.
One can argue that both the Irish and the Salvadoran church leaders have bad track records.  Once Ireland gained independence from Britain, the country’s clergy were among its most powerful figures (some have called Ireland at that time a Vatican colony!). Before becoming Dublin’s archbishop, John Charles McQuaid was a major architect of the Irish constitution, constructed on the principle that Irish law should reflect Catholic doctrine. The constitution specifically notes the "special position of the Holy Catholic Apostolic and Roman Church" in national life. As Scholar Timothy White wrote:
By the time [Irish leader Eamon] De Valera wrote and Ireland enacted a new constitution in 1937, the Catholic religion was guaranteed a special role in society and the entire document adapted principles of corporatism that were popular in Church thinking at that time….De Valera’s constitution provided an effective and formal merger between the Catholic Church and the Irish nationalist elites.
Ireland was, as the New York Times wrote, “a theocracy in all but the name.” Many public institutions (like the schools) were in fact run by the Church. Several generations were thus raised by a domineering and harsh hierarchy who taught a version of Catholicism obsessed with rules and sex and guilt.  The result was not only a morally repressive culture but an appalling array of oppressive Catholic institutions (from parishes to schools to hospitals to convents to orphanages to homes for single mothers) that achieved the psychological and even physical enslavement of many Irish Catholics.
In my first parish job, in 1972, I asked the pastor and his assistant priest, both Irish nationals, why they had come to America to work.  Without hesitation or reflection, both give the same answer: “I came to escape the Irish clergy.” Since then, revelations of widespread clergy sex abuse and exploitation of girls has reinforced popular disgust with the hierarchy.
In El Salvador, the story was slightly different.  Independence from Spain left in place a moneyed elite that owned most of the country’s land and dominated its institutions, including the Church itself.  The Salvadoran clergy, as part of the country’s small educated elite, came mostly from the wealthy landowner families.  This was especially true of many Salvadoran bishops.
Thus El Salvador’s Catholic leadership maintained a longtime partnership with the ruling elite (including the military) that maintained its status by perpetuating the gap between rich and poor.  By preaching that their suffering was God’s will, the hierarchy helped keep the poor in their place.
But by Romero’s time, the hierarchy was shifting its mission, as Vatican II (1962-1965) inspired change in the Church in Latin America. At the historic Medellín (Colombia) conference in 1968, the region’s bishops decided to abandon their traditional role as defender of the status quo and to support the poor struggling for social justice.
Romero was known as a conservative, skeptical of both Vatican II and Medellín. Yet on his appointment as Archbishop of San Salvador in 1977, Romero became almost immediately outspoken in opposing injustice and defending the poor. He had witnessed the suffering poor and government violence even against priests in his previous role as bishop in Santiago de María, which made him distrust authorities and fear for his people.

Oscar Romero had the courage to break with bad leadership and lead another way.  He took the side of the poor, decried their oppression, and became a prophetic voice for all the marginalized and destitute of El Salvador.  But this break made him not only a threat to the elites but even a traitor to his class, and his punishment was assassination during Mass at the hands of a government-sponsored death squad.
The 1980 Funeral of Oscar Romero
Thus Romero became a blessed martyr because he championed the suffering poor against their powerful oppressors.  In this he communicated the truth of the Gospel.
But the Irish hierarchy, meanwhile, was not the partner of an elite oppressor - -it was itself the perpetrator of oppression.  And unlike Romero, it never broke from its harsh and abusive practices.  Instead, as Ireland grew more prosperous and Ireland’s links to other countries (especially the U.S.) grew stronger, the nation’s culture drifted away from the rule of bishops.  In effect, the Irish began to assert a “second independence” (first from the British, now from the Church).  The huge turnout for the gay marriage referendum and a 2-to-1 vote in favor was the result.  For many, the vote was not so much about redefining civil marriage, or about accepting gays, or even about expanding constitutional rights.  Instead, for many Irish voters, this was their “Declaration of Independence” from the Catholic hierarchy.
For me, the lessons from El Salvador and Ireland are obvious and important.  First, leadership that distorts Catholic tradition to serve some other agenda (especially the preservation power) is bad leadership, so finally people refuse to follow.  Second, defending systematic inequality as God’s will is one such distortion of our faith.  Third, rule by sexual repression is another such a distortion of faith.  Fourth, only by breaking away from such distortions and preaching the authentic Gospel message can Catholic leaders restore people’s confidence in their own leaders.  Only then will people follow the leader.
For American Catholics, these lessons invite reflection.  If we are losing members, especially young members, is our leadership somehow responsible?  Has our hierarchy championed the Gospel message?  Has it been, like Jesus, committed to “preach good news to the poor”? Has it, like Jesus, chosen “to proclaim freedom for the prisoners and recovery of sight for the blind, to release the oppressed”?
Or has our hierarchy too often complacently accepted the growing gap between the 1% in the 99%?  Has it too often been sidetracked by its “culture wars” obsession with all things sexual?  Has it lost the trust of millions of millennials by its horrific failure to protect children and discipline their priestly molesters? 
In short, is the hemorrhage of U.S. Catholics best understood not as a crisis of faith among the young, but rather as a crisis of credibility of among our leaders?

Blessed Oscar Romero inspires millions of Catholics (in America as well as El Salvador) as a model of holy, courageous, and effective leadership.  Does he also inspire our bishops?  Can they become credible leaders like him?  If yes, perhaps more of us will be inspired to follow them.
© Bernard F. Swain PhD 2015

Thursday, November 20, 2014

#424: All in the Francis Family?

The 2014 Synod on the Family offered echoes of the past and hopeful clues to the future.


Last month’s Synod on the Family in Rome is still fresh news for two reasons.  First, its work will not really be done until the end of another Synod, to take place in the fall of 2015.  Second, the work the Synod has accomplished already provides significant pointers for the direction of Catholic life.

The Synod is shaping up, in fact, as the most promising transformative event in Catholicism since Vatican Council II (1962-1965).  For me, the Synod so far is notable for four things: (1) the leadership of Pope Francis; (2) the echoes of dynamics and themes from Vatican II; (3) the echoes of Vatican II documents; (4) the struggle to accept the truth about civil marriage.

1. The Leadership of Pope Francis.  It is obvious by now that the phenomenal worldwide popularity of Francis is due more than anything else to his personal manner.  In organizing the Synod, his style once again has reminded many of us of Pope John XXIII (who convened Vatican II). 

For one thing, Francis appears decisive, and unafraid of criticism.  For another, he stresses the pastoral dimensions of church life over the doctrinal requirements:  he speaks much more of God’s mercy than of “truth” or rules.  Francis showed this in his choice last spring of Cardinal Walter Kasper of Rottenburg-Stuttgart (Germany) to deliver an address to prepare for the Synod.
Kasper
Kasper, true to his progressive reputation, suggested the possibility of changes in the Church’s pastoral approach to divorced and remarried couples.  Francis’ style also showed September 14 at Saint Peter’s Basilica, when he presided over the weddings of 20 couples, some of whom were living together.

It showed again in his decision to have real live married couples address the Synod fathers, including one couple who spoke of their friends’ decision to accept their daughter’s same-sex partner. 

We have had many Synods since Vatican II, but none directed by a pope who acts like St. John XXIII.
Saint John XXIII in 1963
2. Echoes of Vatican II. Francis is, after all, the first pope since John XXIII who was not a bishop at Vatican II. He experienced it like the rest of us—he received its work as a challenge. He knows its history, and clearly he feels that its potential has not been fully realized.  No surprise, then, that his style reflects an attempt to complete John XXIII’s work.

Francis’ final address to the Synod reminds us of the addresses both John XXIII and Paul VI gave at Vatican II. He speaks of reading the signs of the times, of learning how to respond to contemporary challenges, of learning how to rethink the tradition in contemporary terms rather than reacting negatively to simply avoid reform. 

This stress on how best to reach out to the world around us, to focus on helping people rather than protecting doctrine, harkens back to the dynamics and climate of Vatican II, which Paul VI described as pervaded by a tone of “profound optimism.”
Pope Paul VI
 One Vatican spokesperson express the same outlook when he suggested that talking of unmarried couples “living in sin” or of gay people’s “disordered orientation”  is not the kind of language that attracts people to the Catholic Church.
Of course, there was a great deal of polarization among the hierarchy at Vatican II, and the same has been true of the Synod, to the point where some bishops have quietly talked about the danger of schism. This recalls Cardinal Ottaviani, the most conservative bishop at Vatican II, publicly hoping to die before Vatican II’s end.  “That way,” he said, “I will still be dying in the Catholic Church.” So too the Synod has begun to surface the misgivings of many conservative bishops about the direction Francis is taking, while also exposing them as minority voices--just as happened at Vatican II.

3. The Documents of the Synod also recall the documents of Vatican II.  When studying the Council, it is usually instructive to compare early drafts with final drafts, because they often showed movement as texts underwent debate, discussion, and finally votes.  The same thing happened in 2014.  Why?  First, because when the majority drafts documents reflecting the majority view, drafts have a reformist, progressive tone that is surprising, even radical.  Second, because the final drafts often step back from such progressive proposals.

This is not because the majority changes its mind, but because the ethos of hierarchical decision-making constantly seeks consensus. 
Synod Session
The documents are voted on, but no one wants a close vote.  Everyone wants each document to receive overwhelming approval (as did the documents of Vatican II).  But getting a “supermajority” requires that final drafts incorporate words and tone which attract the votes of conservative (minority) bishops.

Thus two lessons coming out of Vatican II apply equally well here: First, the final draft of nearly all of such documents is more conservative than earlier drafts because they water down the progressives’ main positions.  Second this means that a strong current at the Synod was more progressive than the final document reveals. So we should read the document’s tone as conservative political packaging of the Synod’s progressive pastoral agenda.

4. Accepting the Truth about Civil Marriage. This conservative shift to garner votes for the final draft was particularly significant with the Synod’s references to both homosexuals in general and homosexual unions in particular.  While earlier drafts had urged the Church to “welcome” gays, the final draft simply proposes that the Church “provide for” them.  And while early drafts suggested that homosexual unions might bring benefits for the partners, the final draft offered no such positive assessment.  In fact, the final draft reflected the bishops concern to stress:

There are absolutely no grounds for considering homosexual unions to be in any way similar or even remotely analogous to God’s plan for marriage.

But even here there may be hope of reform.  For even as the bishops reject equating heterosexual marriage and homosexual unions, at least some bishops are also ready to reject equating civil marriage with the sacrament of Matrimony.  This is significant, since the confusion of civil marriage with Matrimony makes people think that “same-sex marriage” threatens Catholicism’s sacramental teachings.

So far, most bishops--especially U.S. bishops--have claimed to be defending “marriage” without making any distinction between civil marriage and Matrimony.  In short, they have pretended there is only one kind of “marriage.” But of course the reality is that there are two kinds of “marriage” which differ in many significant ways.

First, they are different legally.  Civil marriage is a legal contract, a strictly civil procedure governed by state law and the requirements of the U.S. constitution.  As such, it is a civil right that the government may not deny any citizen without compelling legal justification.  It must be available to all, without prejudice.

Matrimony, by contrast, is a sacred covenant, a sacramental bond governed by the universal canon law of the Church.  It is not a right anyone may claim; rather, the Church reserves its right to determine both who is eligible for Matrimony and whether they meet the necessary preconditions.  It is available, for example, only to Catholics and their partners. 
Weddings at St. Peter's--September 14, 2014
Second, civil marriage and Matrimony are quite different institutions.  Marriages existed everywhere through all history, in all cultures; it shows wide variations in who can get married, what it means, and how it is practiced.  So civil marriage is a much broader institution than Matrimony. That sacrament appeared only since the first century, was found only where Christians lived, and has relatively fixed rules about who can marry, how they marry, and why they marry.


But civil marriage is also a much shallower institution.  It is a simple contractual agreement which may be performed by a justice of the peace without any particular ceremony or ritual.  Matrimony is a sacred covenant performed by the couple themselves (not a justice or a priest), and requires the sacramental rite of Christian Matrimony (as well as several other requirements) to be valid.

Third, these two institutions have quite different purposes and expectations.  The church has developed a clear teaching that Matrimony has two purposes: procreation and the unified life of the couple.  Thus couples must be willing to have children (and raise them Catholic).  Any intention to remain childless nullifies the sacrament.  So does any intention to preserve divorce as an option.  Moreover, the sacrament is not consummated until and unless the couple has (unprotected) sexual intercourse.  (Couples intending to remain celibate require a dispensation.)

Civil marriage, by contrast, has no such requirements.  It is valid whether or not people intend to children or even intend to have sex.  The private life of civilly married couples is not relevant to the civil contract, whose purpose is rather to access a long list of legal and social benefits and privileges (as many as 37 in some states) that only married couples have.  Once a couple completes the civil contract, they are eligible for those benefits and privileges, regardless of their intentions about sexual intimacy or children or family life.  People often think that civil marriage aims at promoting family life, but while that may be a societal benefit of civil marriage, it is not a legal requirement. So civil marriage confers many legal benefits but does not require any family intentions.  Matrimony does require both sex and the intention to have children--but it confers no legal benefits or privileges.

In many countries, these differences are made obvious by having two different ceremonies, but they are masked in the U.S., where the priest performs the civil marriage (acting as an invisible agent of the state!) During the same ceremony when the couple performs the sacrament of Matrimony.

Why do all these differences matter?  Because they totally alter the debate about same-sex marriage.  If marriage and Matrimony were the same thing, then the campaign for same sex marriage would directly  challenge a Catholic sacrament.  If marriage and Matrimony are the same, then “redefining” marriage equates to “redefining” Matrimony.

But if these are two separate institutions, one can redefine one without redefining the other.  Marriage can change while Matrimony stays the same.  This of course, has happened before, when some states prohibited mixed-race couples from marrying even when the Church accepted them for Matrimony.  Eventually these bans changed, but Matrimony stayed the same.

Thus same-sex marriage only threatens Catholic life directly if we insist on pretending that there is only one “institution” of marriage.  For more than 10 years I have been baffled watching the U.S. bishops maintain this pretense, and I’m relieved to see that some of them have finally realized that this does more harm than good. 

The best way to protect the sacrament of Matrimony is, on the contrary, to insist on the truth: Matrimony is not the same as civil marriage.  Thus the sacrament of Matrimony will remain the same no matter what happens to civil marriage.  Any changes in the sacrament would be decided in proper church channels, not by any court or government body.

When the Synod on the Family returns in 2015, we can hope that its work will advance in several ways. 

First, we can hope Pope Francis’ leadership has gathered even more followers (especially among bishops).  Second, we can hope that the optimism of Vatican II is rekindled once and for all.  Three, we can hope that people will treat the Synod documents respectfully but also realistically, so their conservative packaging does not blind us to their reformist core.  And fourth, we can hope that discussions about changes in civil marriage will not be confused with discussions about the sacrament of Matrimony.

   © Bernard   F. Swain PhD 2014

Tuesday, July 2, 2013

#395: The Burden of Proof--Part 2

How the new burden of proof challenges the Catholic Church to honor its own teachings.
 
Now that the Supreme Court has entered the same-sex marriage debate, we have reached a tipping point where voter opinion matters less than the constitutional question of how to justify discrimination that denies gays a civil right.
Now, suddenly, the burden of proof is on those defending the traditional definition of civil marriage.  Now, to make their case, they must prove Bishop Vigneron’s assertion that re-defining civil marriage will “hurt us all.”
Having the burden of proof means that mere assertions will no longer work. They will have to demonstrate concrete harmful consequences.
This is exactly the burden of proof that courts have been demanding for 10 years.  And it is the burden of proof that defenders of “one man and one woman” have been failing to meet in case after case.  So in 2003 the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court addressed the Department of Public Health’s case against gay marriage and concluded:
The department has had more than ample opportunity to articulate a constitutionally adequate justification for limiting civil marriage to opposite-sex unions. It has failed to do so…It has failed to identify any relevant characteristic that would justify shutting the door to civil marriage to a person who wishes to marry someone of the same sex….The absence of any reasonable relationship between, on the one hand, an absolute disqualification of same-sex couples who wish to enter into civil marriage and, on the other, protection of public health, safety, or general welfare, suggests that the marriage restriction is rooted in persistent prejudices against persons...
In this week’s DOMA case, the Supreme Court first noted that DOMA (Defense of Marriage Act) denied gay people their rights by discriminating against them:
The Act’s demonstrated purpose is to ensure that if any state decides to recognize same sex marriages, those unions will be treated as second-class marriages for purposes of Federal law.  This raises a most serious question under the Constitution’s Fifth Amendment….  DOMA writes inequality into the entire United States code.
It then noted the clear and concrete harm from such discrimination: cutting off gay couples from the benefits contained in more than 1000 Federal laws pertaining to “social security, housing, taxes, up to criminal sanctions, copyright, and veterans’ benefits,” as well as health care, bankruptcy, and even children’s benefits.
Next the court reiterated that denying such rights is a major constitutional violation:
DOMA is unconstitutional as the deprivation of the liberty of the person protected by the Fifth Amendment of the Constitution.
Finally it concludes that no defender of DOMA had proved any justification for such a breach of rights:
DOMA singles out a class of persons…The Federal statute is invalid, for no legitimate purpose overcomes the purpose and effect to disparage and injure.
Similarly, in the ruling about California’s Proposition 8, the Court failed to find justification for that law’s ban on gay marriage.  In fact, the absence of such proof led the Court to conclude that those defending the ban had no business in court at all--that is, no legal “standing”:
It is not enough that the party invoking the power of the court had a keen interest in the issue.  That party must also have “standing,” which requires, among other things, that it had suffered a concrete and particularized to injury….We find the petitioners do not have standing.
Once again, the point is that discrimination requires some extraordinary justification:
The equal protection clause requires the state to have a legitimate reason for withdrawing a right or benefit from one group but not others…This requires the litigant to prove that he has suffered a concrete and particularized injury that is fairly traceable to a challenge to conduct, and is likely to be redressed by a favorable judicial decision.
And, the Court concluded, the petitioner never met this burden of proof:
The only individuals who sought to appeal that order were petitioners, who had intervened in the district court.  But the district court had not ordered them to or refrained them from doing anything…. Here… The petitioners have no “direct stake” in the outcome of their appeal.
All this demand for proof of “concrete and particularized injury” could well be too high a burden of proof for Catholic officials to meet. Perhaps it is time that they remind themselves of two things: (1) The difference between civil marriage and the Sacrament of Matrimony, and (2) Catholic teaching on homosexuality.  Until now, the bishops’ strategy has ignored both.
Catholic teaching says homosexuals must be treated with the same respect and dignity as anyone else.  It condemns any “unjust” discrimination against gay people.  If we apply this teaching to the question of civil marriage after 10 years of debate, two things are clear.
First, it is now well established in American law that access to civil marriage is a civil right, which means laws banning gay couples from civil marriage deny gays their rights and are a form of discrimination.
Second, to continue supporting such bans the Catholic Church would need to prove that such discrimination is not “unjust,” since the Church itself condemns that.  It would have to argue that such discrimination is justified because of the harms caused by allowing same-sex civil marriage.  And to do that, it would need to come up with much stronger proof than the courts have seen so far. Is that possible?
Clearly the burden of proving such a case is heavy indeed.  It seems to me that church officials have now three choices:
(1) They can cling to the arguments they had been using for 10 years: pretending that civil marriage is the same as the Sacrament of Matrimony, (even though the first is administered by the priest acting as an agent of the state, and the second is administered by the couple acting as ministers of the Church), and pretending that any change will “hurt us all.” This option guarantees failure.
(2) Or, they can marshall better evidence showing  that redefining civil marriage to allow gay marriage creates concrete harm, and accept the burden of proving that to the American public and the courts.  Legally, this is the only way to stop gay marriage, now that they courts have determined that this is not a matter of majority will but a matter of civil rights. But proving such harm is a tall order, especially since 10 years of gay marriage have convinced growing millions of Americans that no harm has resulted. 
(3) Or, finally, they can acknowledge that civil marriage has taken a historical fork in the road that diverges from the Sacrament of Matrimony, creating two very different institutions—one a civil right governed by the U.S. Constitution, the other a sacrament governed by Catholic tradition.
They can get priests out of the civil marriage business (one wonders: why are they in it at all?). 
They can admit that banning gay civil marriage equals discrimination, and they can also admit that the burden of proof to justify such discrimination has become an impossible task. 
Thus they can conclude that allowing gays access to civil marriage is an act of justice that treats homosexuals with all the respect and dignity that Catholic teaching promises them.
Then the bishops can focus on strengthening the Sacrament of Matrimony, a task they seem to have forgotten.
  © Bernard F. Swain PhD 2013

 

Sunday, June 30, 2013

#394: The Burden of Proof--Part 1

The Supreme Court has shifted the burden of proof in the debate over same-sex marriage.

When I began writing CrossCurrents in 2003, America’s debate over same-sex marriage was just heating up.  Almost immediately, the American Catholic hierarchy made protection of the status quo on marriage a top priority.  They have spent 10 years losing ground, and this week’s Supreme Court rulings confirm what has been clear for some time: the burden of proof is now on the US Bishops and anyone else trying to resist this change.
My doubts about the bishops’ strategy are not new.  In my early CrossCurrents pieces on this issue, I advised that the bishops back civil unions for gays, as Pope Francis did in Argentina.  After the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court overturned a ban on civil marriage licenses for same-sex couples in 2003, I observed that it was time for the U.S.  Catholic Church to get out of the civil marriage business (in which priests act as agents of the state) while the getting was good, in order to focus on the Sacrament of Matrimony.  I wrote:

The bishops could have drawn a sharp line between “civil marriage” and the “Sacrament of Matrimony”. Then they could have defended the unique meaning of Christian marriage against evolving, secular versions of civil marriage. Instead, the bishops chose to meet the court on its own turf, arguing that the good of society depends on denying same-sex couples, and lobbying against any broadening of civil marriage.

Thus the bishops dug in their heels by talking about “marriage” as though civil marriage and sacramental Matrimony were the same institution, while launching scary warnings about the woes to follow us if gays were to marry one another.

Ten years later, the rising tide has eroded the bishops’ stand, yet they cling to the same losing strategy.  Immediately after the Supreme Court killed the Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA) this week and reinstated a California court’s ruling in favor of gay marriage, Catholic bishops quickly sprung into reaction.  Predictably, they offered only more of the same losing strategy.

Archbishop Alan Vigneron of Detroit said:

Catholics and millions of our fellow citizens will continue to make the case…that marriage cannot be redefined, and that attempts to do so hurt us all.

And Archbishop Salvatore Cordileone of San Francisco hammered away on the theme of the “truth about marriage”:

The federal government ought to respect the truth that marriage is the union of one man and one woman, even where states fail to do so. The preservation of liberty and justice requires that all laws, federal and state, respect the truth, including the truth about marriage...The common good of all, especially our children, depends upon a society that strives to uphold the truth of marriage. Now is the time to redouble our efforts in witness to this truth.

The Bishops’ problem is very simple: by confusing the two institutions of matrimony and civil marriage, they’ve replaced the facts with wishful thinking.  They want to make their case on two grounds: (1) there is one unique, non-negotiable truth about “marriage,” and (2) changing our definition of marriage will “hurt us all.” But both these arguments have become less and less credible over time.

Actually, the “truth about marriage” argument was never very convincing.  It only worked as long as people pretended that “marriage” referred to one thing rather than two different institutions, as I wrote earlier:

Many Catholics can’t tell civil and sacramental marriage apart. They may not realize that in fact civil marriage is a great deal older than sacramental marriage: it existed in archaic cultures, in Egyptian and the Israelite cultures, in Greek and Roman cultures, all before St. Paul ever taught that marriage could be understood as a sign of Christ’s bond with his church. Civil marriage took various forms, with various rules (Israelite men were sometimes required to marry their brother’s widow; Roman men were permitted extra-marital sex with slave-women; Greek men were permitted extra-marital sex with boys). Such rules evolve even within a culture, of course: not long ago most states forbade marriage by mixed-race couples.

But while the Bishops failed to acknowledge this truth, Massachusetts Chief Justice Margaret Marshall stated it plainly in her landmark Goodrich opinion legalizing same-sex marriage:

We begin by considering the nature of civil marriage itself. Simply put, the government creates civil marriage. In Massachusetts, civil marriage is, and since pre-Colonial days has been, precisely what its name implies: a wholly secular institution…No religious ceremony has ever been required to validate a Massachusetts marriage.

The truth is that “civil marriage” is an invention of the government, and different governments have defined it differently for centuries.  Moreover, this re-defining has included the evolving recognition that civil marriage, unlike the Sacrament of Matrimony, is a civil right that people make claim access to as a matter of justice:

The benefits accessible only by way of a marriage license are enormous, touching nearly every aspect of life and death. The department states that "hundreds of statutes" are related to marriage and to marital benefits...It is undoubtedly for these concrete reasons, as well as for its intimately personal significance, that civil marriage has long been termed a "civil right."

Without the right to marry…one is excluded from the full range of human experience and denied full protection of the laws…Because civil marriage is central to the lives of individuals and the welfare of the community, our laws assiduously protect the individual's right to marry against undue government incursion. Laws may not "interfere directly and substantially with the right to marry…"There can be no prohibition of marriage except for an important social objective and reasonable means."

There are two consequences of this fact.  First, civil marriage is now being drawn into the general history of civil rights.  Second, this history now challenges Catholic teaching to practice what it preaches about the just treatment of homosexuals.

First, on general history, Marshall wrote:

The history of constitutional law "is the story of the extension of constitutional rights and protections to people once ignored or excluded."…This statement is as true in the area of civil marriage as in any other area of civil rights.

In this week’s DOMA case, the Supreme Court saw this at work as well in New York State:

The limitation of lawful marriage to heterosexual couples, which for centuries have been deemed both necessary and fundamental, came to be seen in New York and certain other states as an unjust exclusion…New York acted to enlarge the definition of marriage to correct what its citizens and elected representatives perceived to be an injustice they had not earlier known or understood.

This movement linking civil marriage to all other civil rights explains the rising tide of court decisions favoring a new definition of marriage.  For if keeping the “one man and one woman” definition means denying gay people in a civil right, the question arises: how can that be justified? It becomes a matter of justice.

This explains why the movement to accept same-sex marriage has been so rapid: from one state in 2003 to 13 and counting in 2013. Now 40% of gay Americans already have access to this civil right, and the rest are demanding to know why they should be denied their rights.

This has dramatically shifted the burden of proof away from those proposing change; they now have both the rhetoric and the reality of civil rights on their side.

NEXT: How the new burden of proof challenges the Church to honor its own teachings.

  © Bernard F. Swain PhD 2013

Sunday, June 9, 2013

#393: Lost and Found--Pope Francis Retrieves Vatican II

After nearly 35 years of Catholic officials obscuring the vision of Vatican Council II, the new pope may already be rescuing its legacy.

The recent homily in which Pope Francis proclaimed Christ has redeemed all humanity, even atheists, has triggered seemingly endless commentary in the media - - print, electronic, and online. (homily text & video at http://en.radiovaticana.va/news/2013/05/22/pope_at_mass:_culture_of_encounter_is_the_foundation_of_peace/en1-694445).

But most of it misses the point.  Amid the debates--over “Did the pope endorse universalism?” or “What is the difference between redemption and salvation?”--most observers (other than James Carroll) miss these facts: (1) Francis’ remark about atheists was neither new nor controversial; (2) his real shift was to leap back over the legacy of John-Paul II and Benedict XVI to invoke the extroverted optimism of Paul VI.  He thus retrieved Vatican II’s version of the Church’s mission - - a version that has been out of favor for 35 years.

Francis may be simple, but he is not simple-minded, so his startling break with his predecessors is couched in his soft proposal to build a “culture of encounter.”

Why does this matter?  Because an “encounter culture” is quite different from the “counter-culture”--and that difference could re-set the Church’s course for years to come.

If memory serves, I first heard the Church described as a “counter -culture” nearly 30 years ago, when Bernard Law took
Bernard Law
over the Archdiocese of Boston in 1984.  Six years after the election of John Paul II, he used the term to express his conviction that Catholicism should not conform or even adapt its traditions to the demands of modern culture.  Rather than blend Catholic faith with the surrounding secular culture, he wanted Catholics to hold fast to an alternative way of life that would “counter” prevailing mores and values.

Back then I found his terminology clever but troubling.  As a child of the 1960s, I already considered myself a proud member of the “counter-culture”--but to me that meant a wave of progressive movements ranging from rock music to civil rights to antiwar politics to the sexual revolution to the questioning of all authority, including church authority.  We were rebelling against much of post-World War II American culture: its conformity, its complacency, its superficiality, its materialism, its militarism, its racism, its spiritual impoverishment.

What Bernard Law called “culture-culture” meant something quite different.  It included scolding Boston College (as well as the students and parents gathered for commencement) for not being true to  its Catholic identity.  It included refusing to allow women to serve as Eucharistic ministers.  It included refusing to allow a Knights of Columbus fundraiser to serve alcohol.  It included forcing the Archdiocese’s charismatics to move their annual conference to the cathedral (despite its inadequate seating capacity) and then imposing his own agenda on the day.  Law was not into questioning authority.  For him, “counter-culture” meant imposing authority to make sure Catholics behaved the way he wanted them to.

I admit I resented this theft and reshaping of the term “counter-culture.” But I soon learned he was not alone. Increasingly in the 1980s and 1990s, US bishops, conservative commentators, and some theologians promoted the “counter cultural” mission of the Church on issues like abortion, sexual morality, “catholic identity,” priestly celibacy, sex education, and eventually same-sex marriage. 

They were so successful that the term “counter-culture” lost its original meaning for people like me, and came to be a code-word for a move to establish a certain understanding of Vatican Council II. This understanding saw the modern world embracing a “culture of death” and countered it with a “culture of life.” The opposition was as clear as black and white, and treated every church position as non-negotiable.
Vatican II

Within the Church itself, this movement was labeled “the reform of the reform.” It was driven by the belief that Catholicism after Vatican II had become too friendly, too accommodating to the modern world around it, and was in jeopardy of losing its own identity.  Supposedly this was the fault of those who exploited the “reforms” of Vatican II as an excuse to abandon traditional teachings and practices in favor of every new cultural trend.  Only by “reforming the reforms” could the Church achieve its “true mission” as a counter-culture.

That is why, in rejecting this view, Pope Francis is provoking such reactions.  In theory, no one is more “counter” to Christian faith than an atheist.  Yet Francis asserted that:

The Lord has redeemed all of us, all of us, with the blood of Christ: all of us, not just Catholics.  Everyone!...  Even the atheists.  Everyone!

This is what Francis means by a “culture of encounter”: that whoever does good, regardless of their beliefs, creates a common ground where we can meet one another:

If we, each doing our own part, if we do good to others, if we meet there, doing good, and we go slowly, gently, little by little, we will make that culture of encounter: we need that so much. We must meet one another doing good. ‘But I don’t believe, Father, I am an atheist!’ But do good: we will meet one another there.

Such talk rings loud echoes for me of the talk Pope Paul VI gave at the final session of Vatican II in 1965:

Secular humanism, revealing itself in its horrible anti-clerical
Pope Paul VI
reality has, in a certain sense, defied the council. The religion of the God who became man has met the religion (for such it is) of man who makes himself God. And what happened? Was there a clash, a battle, a condemnation? There could have been, but there was none. The old story of the Samaritan has been the model of the spirituality of the council. A feeling of boundless sympathy has permeated the whole of it…But we call upon those who term themselves modern humanists…to give the council credit at least for one quality and to recognize our own new type of humanism: we, too, in fact, we more than any others, honor mankind.

Paul is clearly talking about an encounter between the Church and secular culture that can produce a working partnership--and he knew full well that some Catholics would criticize the openness required for such an encounter:

The council…has been deeply committed to the study of the modern world. Never before perhaps, so much as on this occasion, has the Church felt the need to know, to draw near to, to understand, to penetrate, serve and evangelize the society in which she lives; and to get to grips with it, almost to run after it, in its rapid and continuous change. This attitude, a response to the distances and divisions we have witnessed over recent centuries…between the Church and secular society—this attitude has been strongly and unceasingly at work in the council; so much so that some have been inclined to suspect that an easy-going and excessive responsiveness to the outside world, to passing events, cultural fashions, temporary needs, an alien way of thinking...may have swayed persons and acts of the ecumenical synod, at the expense of the fidelity which is due to tradition…We do not believe that this shortcoming should be imputed to it, to its real and deep intentions, to its authentic manifestations.

Observers have mostly overlooked this key fact about Francis: he is the first post-Vatican II pope!  The last five popes were all participants of the Council between 1962 and 1965, but Francis was only a seminary student.  He heard about the Council like the rest of us, from various reports and the media and perhaps by word of mouth. Unlike Benedict, who by the Council’s end felt it was moving too far and getting out of his control, Francis received the Council’s work as a blessing.  He took Pope Paul’s openness as an inspired vision.  Indeed, in his homily he warned against negative attitudes that insist on a “counter-culture” instead of an “encounter.” As reported by Vatican Radio, he contrasts the “counter” of the apostles with the “encounter” of Jesus:

The disciples, Pope Francis explains, “were a little intolerant,” closed off by the idea of ​​possessing the truth, convinced that “those who do not have the truth, cannot do good.” “This was wrong...Jesus broadens the horizon.” Pope Francis said, “The root of this possibility of doing good – that we all have – is in creation.”

Francis is, in effect, depicting Jesus as a bridge-builder among people.  This fits perfectly with our belief that Jesus is the Christ that bridges the gap, not only between people, but also between the human family and the divine family we called Trinity.  And this also fits perfectly the role of the pope, whose titles include “Pontiff” (from pontifex, meaning bridge-builder).

Francis demonstrates reaching out to Encounter
Francis contrasts this open-minded bridgebuilding encounter with the close-minded attitude that leads to conflict: “This ‘closing off’ that imagines that those outside, everyone, cannot do good is a wall that leads to war.”

This reminds us again of Paul VI, who described the Church's role in the world this way addressing the United Nations in 1965:
We here celebrate the epilogue of a weary pilgrimage in search of a conversation with the entire world, ever since the command was given to us: Go and bring the good news to all peoples.
Paul VI Addressing the UN General Assembly
 I, for one, am delighted and encouraged to hear the new pope talk this way.  Such talk is important not because it is about atheists but because it is about Catholics.  Francis is saying we should not be a people content to “counter” those who differ with us.  We must, as a matter of our faith, have the courage to “encounter” them.  
This means we must engage in a true conversation--not simply sharing our faith-based message, but also listening to the message of modern, even secular culture with an openness to the possibility that its message also brings wisdom that can enhance and enrich us.

Not only that, but Francis is saying we must build an “encounter culture” that leads away from conflict to the peace that Christ promised:

“Doing good” is a principle that unites all humanity, beyond the diversity of ideologies and religions, and creates the “culture of encounter” that is the foundation of peace.

For me, there is hope yet that the real renewal of Vatican Council II has not been lost on this pope, a man who has the wisdom to see the dangers lurking in the modern world but also has the courage to reach out and encounter it.  This was the true message of Vatican II, which has been nearly lost amid all the “counter-culture” negativism of recent Catholic leadership. I’m beginning to think that Francis is just the man to rescue Vatican II for us--just in the nick of time.

  © Bernard F. Swain PhD 2013